Call us at 407-630-9766

The Pros and Cons of Buying a Historic House in Florida

Published on Apr 29, 2025 | Purchasing a Home Jhenesis Mortgage Mortgage FAQ historic homes Florida buying historic house Florida historic properties historic home financing historic home maintenance historic neighborhoods Florida
The Pros and Cons of Buying a Historic House in Florida
The Pros and Cons of Buying a Historic House in Florida

By Stacy Ann Stephens, Senior Loan Officer at Jhenesis Mortgage

Why Buy a Historic Home in Florida?

Florida is home to charming historic properties, from Victorian-era homes in St. Augustine to Craftsman bungalows in Tampa. Buying a historic home offers a unique opportunity to own a piece of the Sunshine State’s rich history. Here’s why you might consider one, along with key factors to watch out for.

Unique Design and Craftsmanship

Historic homes in Florida often boast intricate details like hand-carved woodwork, stained glass windows, and grand fireplaces. High ceilings with ornate plasterwork or heart pine floors add a timeless charm that’s rare in modern construction. These features make each home a one-of-a-kind masterpiece, perfect for those who value individuality.

Strong, Lasting Construction

Many historic homes were built with superior materials, such as old-growth timber and solid masonry, designed to withstand Florida’s humid climate and occasional storms. A home that’s stood for a century—through hurricanes and heat—is a testament to its durability, offering peace of mind for buyers.

A Connection to the Past

Owning a historic home in Florida means becoming part of its story. Your home might have ties to notable figures or events, like the early days of Miami’s Art Deco movement or Jacksonville’s Gilded Age. This historical significance adds both emotional and potential resale value.

Great Neighborhoods

Florida’s historic homes are often found in vibrant, established neighborhoods like Winter Park, Coral Gables, or Fernandina Beach. These areas offer walkable access to downtowns, top schools, and community parks, fostering a strong sense of belonging and convenience for residents.

What to Watch Out For

While historic homes are full of charm, they come with unique challenges. Here are the key considerations for Florida buyers.

Higher Maintenance Costs

Older homes often require more upkeep, especially in Florida’s harsh climate. Aging plumbing, electrical systems, or tile roofs can lead to costly repairs. Budgeting for regular maintenance is essential to preserve the home’s integrity.

Limited Renovation Options

If your home is listed on Florida’s historic register or located in a preservation district, strict guidelines may limit exterior or structural changes. These rules protect the home’s character but can restrict modern updates, so check local regulations before buying.

Comfort and Efficiency

Historic homes may have outdated layouts, limited insulation, or smaller closets, which can affect comfort. Upgrading HVAC systems or adding energy-efficient windows can improve livability but may require significant investment, especially in Florida’s hot climate.

Hidden Repairs

Unseen issues, like termite damage or outdated wiring, may only surface during renovations. A thorough inspection by a Census of Population and Housing professional familiar with Florida’s historic homes can help you avoid costly surprises.

Making the Right Choice

Buying a historic home in Florida is a rewarding but complex process. Follow these steps to make an informed decision:

  • Do Your Research: Investigate the home’s history and any preservation restrictions, especially in historic districts like Key West or Pensacola. 
  • Work with Professionals: Hire inspectors and contractors experienced with Florida’s older homes to assess the property’s condition.
  • Budget for Extra Costs: Set aside funds for maintenance, repairs, and potential upgrades to meet modern standards.
  • Take Your Time: Restoring a historic home can be a labor of love, so be prepared for longer timelines.
  • Appreciate the Character: Embrace the home’s unique quirks, from creaky floors to vintage fixtures, while making thoughtful updates.

Final Thoughts

Buying a historic home in Florida is more than a purchase—it’s an investment in history, character, and community. With careful planning and the right financing, you can turn a historic property into your dream home. As Florida’s real estate market remains competitive, now is a great time to explore these unique properties.

Ready to buy a historic home in Florida? As a Senior Loan Officer with Jhenesis Mortgage, I’m here to help you navigate financing options tailored to your needs. Contact me today to discuss your personalized mortgage plan and take the first step toward owning a piece of Florida’s past.

FAQs About Buying a Historic Home in Florida

What are the benefits of buying a historic home in Florida?
Historic homes offer unique designs, durable construction, historical significance, and prime locations in established neighborhoods like St. Petersburg or Orlando.

Are there financing options for historic homes?
Yes, specialized mortgage products, like renovation loans, can help cover purchase and repair costs. Contact Jhenesis Mortgage for personalized options.

How do I know if a home is on Florida’s historic register?
Check with your local historic preservation office or the Florida Division of Historical Resources to confirm the home’s status and any restrictions.

What are common issues with historic homes in Florida?
Common challenges include higher maintenance costs, outdated systems, and potential renovation restrictions, particularly in humid climates.

Can I modernize a historic home?
Yes, but updates must often comply with preservation guidelines. Work with contractors experienced in historic renovations to balance modern comfort and historical integrity.

Ready to own a piece of Florida’s history? Contact Stacy Ann Stephens at 407-630-9766 or Jhenesis Mortgage today to explore financing options for your historic home purchase. Call now or visit our website to get started!

Thinking about buying a historic home? Let’s talk about your financing options and how you can make your move today. Reach out for a personalized mortgage plan.

Recent Posts

Blog Tags

Mortgage Assumption Purchasing a Home Home Equity Loan Home Refinance Refinancing a Home VA Loans Homeownership The Loan Process Credit Interest Rates Investor Loans DSCR Loan Mortgage Broker bank statement loan short term rental loans Down Payment Assistance Green Real Estate Sustainable Properties Real Estate Investing Real Estate Lending Trends CreditScore FICO10T VantageScore4 Jhenesis Properties CreditScoreChanges Mortgage FAQ Jhenesis Mortgage fixed-rate HELOC borrow against home equity financial stability home improvement loan debt consolidation tuition funding FHA gift funds FHA-approved gift fund sources Using gift funds for down payment FHA loan limits Housing market 2025 loan limits Non-QM loans for self-employed Flexible home financing options Non-QM loans for real estate investors Alternative mortgage solutions 2025 Self-employed mortgage options Different types of mortgage loans Top mortgage options explained Best mortgage loans for first-time buyers Comparing mortgage loan types Choosing the right home loan Mortgage pre-approval validity How long does pre-approval last? Mortgage pre-approval expiration Pre-approval timeline for homebuyers When does a mortgage pre-approval expire? What to ask your mortgage broker Top mortgage lender questions Mortgage questions for first-time buyers How to choose the right mortgage lender Sales price vs appraised value Difference between sales price and appraisal What happens if appraisal is lower than sales price down payment assistance zero money out of pocket NACA program details seller credits first-time homebuyer programs no money out of pocket Minimum credit score for a mortgage Credit score tips for first-time homebuyers How credit score impacts mortgage rates Improving credit for buying a house FHA loans and credit scores Bad credit home loans First-time homebuyer credit score requirements saving for a mortgage down payment first-time homebuyer savings down payment strategies how to save for a down payment 3-2-1 buydown mortgage buydown reduce mortgage payments affordable mortgage options first-time homebuyer financing mortgage interest rate reduction 3-2-1 buydown benefits temporary interest rate reduction home equity how to build home equity home equity loan HELOC cash-out refinance fixer-uppers homeownership mortgage tips affordable housing hazard insurance Florida Florida homeowners insurance mortgage requirements Florida homebuying journey Florida hurricane insurance flood insurance Florida Florida mortgage for young buyers first-time homebuyer Florida low-down-payment programs Florida Florida homeownership young buyers Florida DTI ratio first-time homebuyer programs Florida historic homes Florida buying historic house Florida historic properties historic home financing historic home maintenance historic neighborhoods Florida buying a foreclosure in Florida Florida foreclosure homes foreclosure pros and cons foreclosure financing Florida real estate VA loans Florida VA home loans zero down mortgage Florida veterans home loans low interest VA loans veteran mortgage benefits challenge low home appraisal Florida home appraisal inaccurate appraisal reconsideration of value Florida school districts Florida school ratings Buying a home in Florida best school districts buy a home with no down payment Florida Florida mortgage options down payment assistance Florida first-time homebuyer Florida